Comments

88 Comments

• At 2009.08.13 02:55, Brenda Le said:

  Wow - I was pretty close! LOL!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 02:59, Camila said:

  hahahha yep they look the same. What do you mean in texture? Do you recommend better de NARS shadows?

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.08.14 02:00, sixx said:

    Powdery, chalky, satin-smooth, creamy, etc…

    [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 03:04, Martha M said:

  lol I was way off.. I actually guessed the NARS shadows were the NYX ones for a lot of them. Cherry Culture’s sold out of Exotic Green, I believe. I hope they restock soon, the color looks so nice.

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.08.13 12:01, Madeleine said:

    I know! I wanted Exotic Green, but they were sold out pretty fast.. darn.

    [Reply]
    • At 2009.08.13 15:41, Yams said:

      Exotic Green is so amazing!

      I’m thinking of grabbing Golden Amber sometime as well.

      [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 03:13, Qt_Mousie said:

  lol..got 2 outta 5 right…the others were completely missed mixed

  the more I look at, the more i’m liking sensual

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 03:17, Poe88 said:

  The green one I think is NARS Night Porter…she used Night Flight twice.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 04:22, Elisa said:

  i got 2 right.. lol NYX shadows are always impressive :]

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 05:21, Audrey said:

  I didn’t even try to guess, cos I never tried Nars on NYX. I love the colours though, and if I had to choose, I’d definitely go for NYX

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 08:15, sprut6 said:

  I can’t get over how good these dupes are! Gorgeous…

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.08.22 13:42, Giselle said:

    yap!!! its good for people that dont want to spend lots of money

    [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 08:37, melli068 said:

  Nyx is amazing

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.08.13 14:44, itskimdo said:

    yea i wasn’t going to buy these colors now i think i will

    [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 08:45, bumblebeez82 said:

  wow! that is super close. I’m going to check out their website right now. I havene’t seen such colors be soooooo similar but their price not…

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 09:51, Marce said:

  Oh I missed out on the guessing! It’s not surprising that you can get a super luxe eyeshadow for a quarter of the price…

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 09:52, lauren pahati said:

  I love saving money n spending as well LOL um do they hav this at ulta … I actually like the nyx clubbing better than the nars ! but do they feel the same?

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.09.13 00:21, husbandand2girls said:

    I’m curious to know where I can find NYX in Ulta as well. I don’t always like to shop online. In the event that I want something right now, and not later, do the or any other store that you know of carry it?

    [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 11:04, Joliz said:

  Damn I’m sad I missed out on the guessing game, but I totally want to buy some of those NYX colors now, awesome payoff

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 11:17, karrie said:

  Unbelievable.
  I am going to check out these dupes.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 11:56, amanda said:

  They look almost identical

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 12:02, Madeleine said:

  Thank gosh for NYX and their prices, it’s so affordable, especially now when MAC’s got a new collection coming out and I am eyeing so many stuff from their new collection..Ouch!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 12:28, Tee said:

  I got them all right! NYX shadows are awesome. I wish their website would ship where I live.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 12:40, Dw T said:

  I couldn’t guess, they looked so similar.

  [Reply]
  • At 2009.08.22 13:44, Giselle said:

    yes and that good, in my country u cant find nars nor mac (well u can find mac but theres only like 10 stores i think around the country ) make up so nyx its a good option!!!

    [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 12:46, ceeceebeex3 said:

  yay i was right nyx vs nars but its ok it was fun guessing !

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 12:59, heather said:

  from the picts it looks like nars had more fall out. very interesting!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 14:22, Makeup and Me said:

  NARS seems more intense…but NYX are great dupes..definitely worth getting

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 14:40, baybee415 said:

  ahhhhhhhhhhh

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 14:49, pinkyflash4 said:

  they look pretty much the same!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 14:52, Blissinmycoffee said:

  Goodness. They’re so similar. This really makes me not want to buy NARS makeup since I can get the same quality but for cheaper with NYX

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 15:44, Melody said:

  wow I know!
  the colors are very similar
  and i like that its kinda like dupes for the more expensive brand
  i will definitely have to go get those NYX ones.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 16:38, marivel said:

  wow they are very similar!
  big kudos to NYX =D

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 16:54, MsKia said:

  Sweet, think I’m going to invest what little money I have into grabbing some NYX colors. Especially if I walk into Sephora and start getting the buying itch…I’ll just walk right out and onto the nearest drugstore!!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 17:48, Karell said:

  The colors definitely look the same on camera! The blending isn’t the same though..

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 20:27, Kalene said:

  NYX and NARS both have very very very similar colors, but overall, NARS has better quality eyeshadows. I mean, that’s obvious. Lol. It costs wayyy more. NYX has great prices.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 21:44, freewing said:

  the colors look really similar to each other,but Nars has better quality…

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 22:09, Lauren said:

  Just because something costs more does not mean that it is of a better quality. Many times, you are paying for the advertising and the pretty package and nothing more.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.13 22:29, Karen said:

  its so crazy how similar the two are o___o pursebuzz, do you have a tutorial for a look with these kinds of colours? i’d love to see one :]

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 00:20, Michelle said:

  Wow, really similar!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 00:50, Naomi said:

  OMG, seriously? lol i really thought the first blue one was the other way around because of the colour intensity

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 01:42, PandaBaby143 said:

  i love the purple and the green

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 02:26, stacy said:

  WOW they look like the same shadows!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 02:30, tofupoo said:

  lol! trickyyyy

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 02:45, Brigitte said:

  Would it be too much to ask if anyone knows for a dupe of the grey shade in Brumes Nars duo? (:

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 02:54, Michelle said:

  I just used nyx smokey eye palet yesterday, I’m in loveee…woooohhhh hahaha

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 03:56, Claudia said:

  These were great dupes. I was lost don’t own any nars e/s and limited nyx.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 04:58, Janelle said:

  They look so freakishly similar, it’s awesome.

  If only someone could find a relatively cheap dupe for Orgasm blush

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 05:01, ioana said:

  I tought they ore in that order.. to lazy to write :))

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 05:14, Mimosa said:

  This was funny lol

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 05:15, Diana said:

  i guessed 3/5..not bad

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 10:40, Heather said:

  how do they compare texture wise?

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 11:16, Christina said:

  i just cant believe how alike they look!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 16:50, dee said:

  wow! i can;t belive that look alike!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 22:12, Leanna said:

  aw those are pretty fall colorrrs

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 22:45, julie said:

  wow i couldnt even tell haha

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.14 23:03, J said:

  they are so close i can’t tell

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 00:05, ceeceebeex3 said:

  wow the colours are so similar, pigmented and vibrate i should try it out.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 00:47, chunsiewjeh said:

  wow.. thats pretty awesome

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 00:52, kornesican said:

  Wow

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 04:12, evelyn said:

  they look the same!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 07:18, insiya said:

  Wow they look all the same to me !!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 08:21, boots said:

  i friggin’ MUST get those NYX shadows…i <3<3<3 the NARS “night” shadows, but they’ve been too pricey for me to grab ‘em all =XX i was at fragrance outlet the other day and i was like HMM THOSE ARE SOME COLORS I’VE NEVER SEEN BEFORE…but i was in a hurry so couldn’t check them out. ‘glad i didn’t get ‘em there! cherryculture, there will be a haul soon!! :)**

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 09:55, Elizabeth said:

  I couldn’t tell a difference at all. Really love the colors, thanks for this!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.15 23:22, Charisse said:

  Wow! I honestly can’t tell from the swatches w/c one is which. The colors are almost the same.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.16 21:27, christina said:

  again, nicenice payoff nars is wayy pricey

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.17 11:50, Caressa said:

  I love NYX products.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.17 19:30, AAJ83 said:

  oh my…nyx has come out with perfect dupes!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.18 01:08, Jacqueline said:

  Wow very cheap alternative! Thank you for the swatches! I love it

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.19 23:10, aalytah said:

  OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  THEY DONT EVEN LOOK DIFFERENT
  =|
  THANKS PB! =)

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.22 15:32, Nancy said:

  Whoa! These dupes are amazing for an affordable price!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.25 20:07, 808GiRLSCAN said:

  Wow, amazing. they pretty much look the same.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.25 23:27, xsamiieee said:

  wow, without even guessing i wouldve thought they were the same. o.o

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.26 03:40, Janice A. said:

  wow… sold!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.26 17:08, wiccanails said:

  i would of thought that they were the same product wow

  [Reply]
• At 2009.08.30 10:01, sombrerosa said:

  thanks for the dupes!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.09.01 01:25, BitterSweet said:

  I still can’t believe how comparable they are. I just hope the NYX last as long as the Nars because I’m going to buy all of them ^_^ (NYX not Nars, I wish)

  [Reply]
• At 2009.09.08 23:17, Ali said:

  I really like the last purple ones, will you be doing a fall/ easy school eye makeup tutorial or maybe a super fun halloween???!!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.09.11 15:01, Lexia said:

  omg, thanks for finding dupes for nars. nars are way too expensive for me. and i love nyx and their quality.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.09.18 00:47, Amber!! said:

  I so want to buy all of these but i tottaly think that they are amazing, ok that was confusing i am talkin bout the nyx shadows not the nars but i still love nars jeazz im painting myself in a corner so long story short i LOOOOVVVVVEEEEE nyx and they have some of the best quality ever almost if not just as good as mac!!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.11.18 20:43, Missy said:

  this just shows you labels don’t matter its all about quality!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.11.23 04:31, Ann said:

  wow! i cant believe how similar these shadows are!!! i love nyx and i just started trying out their products after watching your videos and now i want more!!!!!!!!

  [Reply]
• At 2009.11.23 17:26, Celine Villanueva said:

  NYX eyeshadows are definitely my GO-TO eye shadows when I’m on a budget, & even when I’m not, because they never disappoint! NEVER! (= Although I haven’t been able to try many of NARS eye shadows bcus I already have NYX alternatives. Haha.

  [Reply]
• At 2009.12.23 02:36, nikkienguyen said:

  I actually like the NYX colors better

  [Reply]
• At 2010.02.24 01:33, LdaniS87 said:

  thanks for letting us know about these dupes, i’m definitely going to check out the nyx blushes now hopefully they’re not too soft thats the only downside but i guess you get what you pay for lol

  [Reply]
• At 2010.02.24 14:41, sycheung said:

  LOL, these colours are pretty much exact dupes! It’s great because now we get alternatives to choose from so we can pick our own preferences, mine is definitely Nars

  [Reply]
• At 2010.02.26 16:39, Jenny said:

  Dang they’re similar!!! I haven’t purchased NYX eye shadows, but I think ill try them out now!

  [Reply]
• At 2010.04.30 12:23, UhhSpork said:

  these are fun, do more of them!

  [Reply]